5 Signs You're Experiencing Unconscious Bias (And What to Do About It)

You're good at your job. You deliver results. You've earned your seat at the table.

But something feels off.

Often, your ideas get attributed to someone else. Your contributions are overlooked in meetings. You're given plenty of work to do, but no raises or promotions go along with it.

You might be experiencing unconscious bias—and trust me, it's not in your head.

Unconscious bias refers to the automatic associations and stereotypes that influence how people perceive and evaluate others, often without awareness. And they can significantly impact your career advancement.

The frustrating part? Unconscious bias is subtle, systemic, and difficult to pinpoint. Unlike overt discrimination, it operates below the surface, making it easy to second-guess yourself or internalize as a personal failure.

Let's examine five concrete signs you're experiencing workplace bias—and what you can actually do about it.

Sign #1: Your Ideas Are Repeated by Others and Get Credit

What it looks like: You share an idea in a meeting and it is met with silence or minimal acknowledgment. Ten minutes later, a colleague restates your exact point, and suddenly everyone agrees. They get the credit.

Why it happens: Research shows that women's contributions in meetings are more likely to be interrupted, dismissed, or attributed to others—particularly in male-dominated fields. This phenomenon, sometimes called "idea theft" or "bropropriation," reflects unconscious associations that link leadership and innovation more strongly with men.

What to do about it:

• Document it immediately. After the meeting, send a recap email: "Thanks for the productive discussion. As I mentioned earlier, [restate your idea]. I'm glad we're moving forward with this approach."

• Use the amplification strategy. Partner with allies who will publicly credit your contributions: "As [Your Name] said earlier..." This technique was famously used by women staffers in the Obama White House.

• Speak up in the moment. Practice a calm, direct response: "I appreciate you building on the point I raised earlier. Let's explore that further."

Sign #2: You're Praised for Execution but Excluded from Strategy

What it looks like: Your manager consistently compliments your reliability and thoroughness. You're trusted with complex implementation work. But when strategic discussions happen—about vision, direction, or big-picture initiatives—you're not in the room. In other words, you're seen as a workhorse and not much more.

Why it happens: Women are frequently recognized for being highly effective at implementation, planning, and getting things done—often referred to as "operational" excellence. Men on the other hand are seen as having more agentic, strategic qualities. Both are silly stereotypes, but it leads to women being pigeonholed as excellent executors while men are viewed as natural strategists—regardless of actual capabilities.

What to do about it:

• Make your strategic thinking visible. Don't wait for permission. In project updates, always connect your work to broader business impact: "This initiative supports our Q3 revenue goals by..."

• Request strategic assignments explicitly. "I'd like to take on more strategic work. Specifically, I'm interested in [type of project]. What would prepare me for that opportunity?"

• Create your own strategic artifacts. Write white papers, proposal documents, or market analyses—even if no one asked. Share them as "thoughts I've been developing."

Sign #3: Your Expertise Is Questioned More Than Your Peers'

What it looks like: In meetings, your data is scrutinized more heavily. Your recommendations require additional validation. Meanwhile, colleagues with similar or less experience have their expertise accepted at face value.

Why it happens: Studies on "prove-it-again" bias show that women and people of color must provide more evidence of competence than their counterparts. One mistake can confirm stereotypes, while repeated successes are attributed to luck or external factors.

What to do about it:

• Build an evidence file. Maintain a "wins document" with quantified achievements, positive feedback, and successful projects. Reference it when challenged: "Based on my work on [X project], which delivered [Y results]..."

• Reframe questions as opportunities. When someone questions your analysis, respond: "That's an important consideration. Here's the additional data that supports this recommendation..." This demonstrates thoroughness without defensiveness.

• Leverage external validation. Client testimonials, industry recognition, and third-party data can bypass internal bias. "This approach aligns with recommendations from [respected industry source]."

Sign #4: You're Given Feedback About Your "Style" Rather Than Your Substance

What it looks like: Performance reviews mention you need to be "more collaborative," "less aggressive," or have "better executive presence." Meanwhile, male colleagues displaying identical behaviors are praised for being "decisive" or "direct." I've written extensively about this phenomenon.

Why it happens: The "double bind" of leadership means women face contradictory expectations. Be assertive, but not too assertive. Be confident, but not arrogant. Show emotion, but don't be emotional. These vague, style-based critiques often mask bias rather than identifying genuine development areas.

What to do about it:

• Ask for behavioral specifics. When given vague feedback, respond: "Can you share a specific example of when my communication style created an issue? What would the ideal approach have looked like?"

• Request comparison criteria. "What does strong executive presence look like at this level? Who demonstrates this well?" This forces more objective standards.

• Document the pattern. If you receive contradictory feedback (too direct/not direct enough), note this. Patterns of impossible-to-satisfy feedback can indicate bias rather than legitimate development needs.

• Focus on measurable outcomes. Redirect conversations to results: "I understand the style feedback. I'd like to also discuss the measurable impact of my work, including [specific achievements]."

Sign #5: You're Excluded from Informal Networks and Visibility Opportunities

What it looks like: Important information gets shared at social events you're not invited to. High-visibility projects go to colleagues who have drinks with leadership. You hear about decisions after they're made.

Why it happens: Affinity bias leads people to mentor, sponsor, and create opportunities for those who remind them of themselves. In male-dominated leadership, this often means informal networks form around golf outings, drinks, or activities where women are underrepresented.

What to do about it:

• Create your own network. Don't wait for invitations. Host strategic coffee meetings, organize cross-functional working groups, or create a peer advisory circle.

• Make visibility requests explicit. "I'm interested in presenting at the quarterly board meeting. What would make me a strong candidate?" or "I'd like to lead the [client/initiative] relationship. How can I position myself for that?"

• Track opportunity distribution. Notice who gets stretch assignments, client-facing roles, or conference speaking opportunities. If there's a pattern, raise it: "I've noticed the last four client presentations went to [demographic]. How are these opportunities allocated?"

• Build sponsors, not just mentors. Identify senior leaders who will advocate for you in rooms you're not in. Make their job easy by regularly sharing your wins and goals.

Moving Forward: From Awareness to Action

Recognizing unconscious bias isn't about blaming individuals—it's about understanding systemic patterns that affect your career trajectory.

Here's your action plan:

Start documenting now. Create a simple tracking system for meetings, projects, and interactions where you notice bias patterns. Note dates, contexts, and specific behaviors. This documentation serves multiple purposes: validating your experiences, identifying patterns, and creating a record if you need to escalate concerns.

Build your case with data. Track your objective contributions: projects delivered, revenue generated, problems solved, clients retained. When bias surfaces, you can point to measurable impact rather than subjective perception.

Develop a strategic response framework. Not every instance of bias requires the same response. Determine your priorities:

• Which battles matter most for your advancement?

• Where can you make change versus where should you document and move on?

• What's your risk tolerance for speaking up?

Invest in your external brand. Your internal reputation shouldn't be your only asset. Build visibility through industry speaking, writing, board positions, or strategic networking. This creates options and leverage.

Know when to stay and when to go. This one can be tough to swallow. But sometimes organizations have cultures where bias is so entrenched that individual strategies hit a ceiling. There's no shame in recognizing when an environment won't change and making a strategic move to an organization that values your contributions.

The Bottom Line

Experiencing unconscious bias doesn't mean you're not capable enough, strategic enough, or leadership material.

It means you're navigating a system that wasn't designed with you in mind.

The goal isn't to change yourself to fit biased perceptions. The goal is to document what's happening, protect your advancement, and make strategic decisions about where to invest your energy.

You've earned your expertise. You've proven your capabilities. Now it's about ensuring you receive the recognition, opportunities, and advancement you deserve.

Well helloooo there! Like what you see here? We'd love to have you as a member of the Expansive Woman Project. We provide content, courses, and community designed to help you take charge of your career. Membership is free, and always will be!

Click here to join now!