Reading Your Boss: Figuring Out What They Actually Need from You
- Judy Sims
- 4 days ago
- 7 min read
My first boss was an 18-year-old manager at a shop called Suzy Shier. Shawna was smart, observant, and a great coach. But most importantly, she was a master communicator. I always knew exactly what was expected of me and she didn’t hesitate to give praise or performance improvement suggestions. Fifteen-year-old me had no idea how good I had it.
Since then, I've had a succession of astoundingly poor communicators. One said "no" to anything slightly risky, but without an explanation or a suggested remedy. It was just, "no". One would enter the office with his phone glued to his ear, walk silently past our team of 15 to his office, where he would immediately shut the door and remain there for most of the day while the company literally crumbled around him. One boss just wanted us to “hustle better” but could never quite describe what the hell that meant.
With a few exceptions, far too many of my bosses have been unreadable. And I’m not alone.
My client Tracey can’t figure out what her new boss wants. And that boss seems to have no interest in letting Tracey in on it. When Tracey tries to communicate with her boss, it somehow goes around in circles, and she’s left more confused than before they talked.
Another client’s boss assigns projects, fails to give any expectations or deadlines, ignores clarifying questions and then gets angry when the team doesn’t deliver whatever she (silently) imagined the outcome to be.
Nobody ever hands you the manual for the person you report to. You get the job description, the org chart, a slightly damp handshake on your first day, and then you're expected to reverse-engineer the entire operating system of a whole human being using nothing but context clues and vibes.
It’s frustrating, but like it or not, a big part of your job to learn to read your boss.
Let me get the obvious objection out of the way, because I can feel you making a face. "Reading your boss" can sound like a polite euphemism for sucking up, and if you've spent your career being the competent one who lets the work speak for itself, the whole idea might make your skin crawl a little. I get it.
The good news is that the people who literally wrote the book on this agree with you. In their classic Harvard Business Review piece Managing Your Boss, John Gabarro and John Kotter are blunt that none of this is about flattery or political maneuvering. Their point is that you and your boss are in a relationship of mutual dependence, and you simply can't do your best work when you don't understand the person who sets your priorities and controls your access to resources.
So let's do it on purpose, and deliberately, the same way you'd learn any other system that has this much say over your future.
Start with what they're actually chasing
Underneath every decision quirk and delivery preference, your boss is running on a small handful of very human drivers, and once you can name the one or two that dominate, an astonishing amount of their behaviour stops looking random and starts looking almost predictable. There are six of these needs in the framework I use with clients, but four of them do most of the heavy lifting when the person you're trying to decode happens to be the one who signs off on your future.
Here's how to spot each one in the wild.
Certainty is the need for safety, stability, and predictability. It’s the quiet drive to know what's coming so nothing catches them off guard. You're dealing with a certainty boss when:
They want the agenda, the deck, and the numbers well before anyone sits down.
Too many variables affecting a decision causes them to panic or shut down.
"Let me sit with it" is a complete sentence they use often.
A bit of a risk gets heard as reckless unless you've already mapped every contingency.
The move: lead with how carefully you've de-risked the thing, and never spring anything on them in front of an audience.
Significance is the need to feel important, respected, and a little bit exceptional. And to be seen that way by the people who matter to them. You're dealing with a significance boss when:
Conversations keep finding their way back to their own track record and hard-won wins.
They dismiss ideas that aren’t their own.
They care more about who gets the credit than they'll ever say out loud.
They light up at "your call was the one that worked" and cool off fast at being overlooked.
They keep one eye permanently on how things are playing with their own boss.
The move: show them how backing your idea makes them look sharp to the people above them.
Variety is the need for novelty, stimulation, and challenge, paired with a very low tolerance for anything that smells like routine. You're dealing with a variety boss when:
They visibly wilt in the fourth identical status meeting.
They collect new tools, ideas, and pilots faster than anyone can possibly implement them.
They reroute a settled plan the moment it starts to feel predictable.
They lean in hardest the second you say "we haven't tried this before."
The move: frame your idea as the fresh and slightly bold experiment nobody else has had the nerve to run.
Connection is the need for belonging, warmth, and genuine relationship, the sense that the people around them are actually with them. You're dealing with a connection boss when:
They open meetings with real human conversation before anyone touches the agenda.
They extend trust based on rapport at least as much as on results.
They treat a tense team dynamic as a five-alarm problem.
They want to know who's already on board before they'll decide whether they are.
The move: bring it as something the team is genuinely excited to build together, and never let them feel like the odd one out.
Most bosses run on one or two of these far more than the rest, and the same proposal will land four completely different ways depending on which one you're speaking to. It's one idea walking through four different doors, and a startling number of good careers stall out simply because a talented person kept knocking on the wrong one.
They tip their hand every time they decide
Watch your how your boss makes decisions. Do they decide fast in the room, or do they need to sit with something overnight before they'll commit to anything? Do they want one clear recommendation with a reason attached, or do they get twitchy when you haven't laid out three viable paths? Bring them the version they actually use, and you graduate from "person who generates work" to "person who makes hard calls easy."
Everybody has a landmine
Your boss is managing up too, and somewhere above them sits a person whose good opinion they're quietly terrified of losing. That fear almost always crystallizes into one specific thing they can't afford to be blindsided by, whether it's a budget surprise, a slipped date that makes them look disorganized, or a client complaint that reaches their boss before it reaches them. Notice that a nasty surprise is exactly what the certainty-driven boss can't tolerate and looking bad in front of leadership is exactly what the significance-driven boss can't survive, so the landmine is almost always wired straight to their dominant need. Your job is to find it well before anyone steps on it. Then you become the person who spots it early and defuses it so quietly that nobody else even registers there was a problem, because nothing on earth builds trust faster than being the reason your boss never gets ambushed.
Watch what they reward, not what they say they value
Every organization has an official value system printed on a wall somewhere, and it's roughly as reliable as a horoscope. If you actually want to know what your boss cares about, ignore the mission statement entirely and read the calendar instead. Where do they choose to spend their real attention? What makes them lean forward in a conversation and put their phone down? Whose name do they say with genuine warmth, and what exactly did that person do to earn it? That's the value system that quietly decides who gets promoted, and it's almost never the tidy one on the poster.
Give it to them the way they can actually hear it
Some bosses are readers, some bosses are listeners, some need a bit of show and tell. A reader wants the memo first so they can process on their own and come back to you with sharpened questions. A listener wants to talk it through out loud and would very much prefer you didn't drop a six-page document on them the night before a decision. A show and tell boss needs to see how it will work – think a white board illustration, or better yet, a prototype. It's the same information delivered in completely different ways and getting it wrong can make genuinely brilliant work land with a thud.
Here's the part I hate to tell you
There's a version of "reading your boss" that's a trap, and high-achieving women get funneled into it constantly. It's the version where you become exquisitely attuned to your boss's moods, remember everyone's birthday, organize the offsite, smooth every ruffled feather in the department, and get warmly thanked right up until the exact moment someone else gets handed the stretch assignment. That's not strategic intelligence, however much it looks like it from the inside. That's office housework in a slightly nicer outfit, and it's got a very well-documented habit of keeping capable women parked precisely where they already are.
The kind of boss-reading that actually moves your career is another kind entirely. It's the kind where you take everything you've learned about how they decide and what keeps them awake at night and you use it to become the person who solves their genuinely hard problems, out loud, in the rooms where leadership is paying attention. One version of this gets you thanked and the other version gets you sponsored, so learn to tell them apart quickly and spend your finite energy accordingly.
If you're doing consistently excellent work and still watching other people get promoted straight past you, the gap is almost never your competence. It's usually strategic, it's usually about who can see what you're carrying, and it's usually far more fixable than it feels at eleven o'clock at night. That's the entire reason The Expansive Woman Project exists.
Well helloooo there! Like what you see here? We'd love to have you as a member of the Expansive Woman Project. We provide content, courses, and community for women who are done waiting for their next promotion. Membership is free, and always will be!
