How to Fight for Your Team Without Being Called "Difficult"

For the past two years, my client Vivian has been trying to get two new hires approved for her search marketing team. Her team is stretched waaaaay too thin. Their work is relentless, highly specialized, meticulous, and let’s face it, not all that glamorous (which means they don't get a lot of recognition in the organization). In short, they are highly effective invisible workhorses who are currently running on fumes.

A few weeks ago, I received an emergency call from Vivian just as she got out of a budget meeting. Her team's headcount request was denied. Again. And at the same time, a guy two floors up whose team is half the size of her and produces a quarter of the output, somehow walked out with his two new hires approved.

When Vivian asked her skip level why she was denied, he simply said, “Stop focusing on building an empire, and just focus on more efficiency with what you have.”

And that’s what prompted the phone call.

Vivian was angry, frustrated, and blaming herself.

“What am I doing wrong?” she asked. “Why am I supposedly ‘building an empire’, when the guy two floors up is just ‘optimizing his team’?”

Have you received bizarre feedback when advocating for your team?

You're not imagining it. The feedback women get often sounds rather different from what our male peers receive.

Here is some actual feedback I've received:

He "advocated strongly for his team." You were "territorial."

He "made a compelling case." You were "difficult."

He "fought for resources." You were "emotional about it."

You may have also heard that you are “not a team player”, “inflexible”, “entitled”, or as in Vivian’s case, “empire building”.

Sisters, let's talk about what's actually happening here — and more importantly, what you can do about it.

The Double Bind Is Real (and Documented)

Before we get into strategy, let's call this what it is. Research published in Psychological Science by Yale's Victoria Brescoll found that men who expressed anger in the workplace received a boost in perceived status. Women who expressed the same anger were consistently accorded lower status and seen as less competent. Same behavior, opposite outcome.

And it goes further. A University of Colorado study found that women who advocated for other women were rated as colder than those who didn't. The moment you visibly fight for your people, you risk being framed as self-interested — even though that's literally part of your job.

This is not a you problem. It's a system problem with a very specific tax attached to it. And until the system changes, you need strategies that work inside it.

The goal here is not to make you small. The goal is to make you effective.

Why Your Team Needs You to Get Good at This

Let's be clear about something: advocating for your team is not optional. It is one of the most important things you do as a leader. When you don't fight for resources, headcount, and recognition, here's what actually happens:

Your best people burn out and leave. Your mid-level people get poached. Your rising stars stop raising their hands. And you're left managing a depleted team with the same expectations attached — which eventually becomes a performance problem with your name on it.

Not advocating is not the safe choice. It's just a slower form of failure.

So you have to do this. The question is how to do it in a way that builds your influence rather than triggering the "difficult woman" penalty.

Five Strategies That Actually Work

1. Make the Business Case, Not the Fairness Case

Here is a hard truth: "We deserve this" is not a business case. "We've been carrying more than our share" is not a business case. Both things may be completely true, and neither will move the needle in a budget meeting.

What does move the needle: revenue impact, risk exposure, and strategic alignment.

Instead of: "My team is stretched and people are burning out."

Try: "At our current capacity, we're the bottleneck on three revenue-generating projects. The cost of that delay over the next two quarters exceeds the cost of one additional hire."

You're not abandoning the fairness argument. You're translating it into the language the decision-makers actually respond to. Those are not the same thing.

Before your next resource conversation, ask yourself: what is the quantified cost to the organization of not investing in my team? Build from there.

2. Make the Data Do the Talking

The "territorial" label gets attached to women regardless of how they frame their ask. "My team needs this" lands the same way as "I want this" when the person saying it is you. So stop trying to find the magic phrasing and focus on removing yourself from the center of the argument altogether.

Data does that. When you walk in with workload metrics, cycle times, output-per-headcount comparisons, or attrition trends, you're not asking for something — you're presenting an organizational situation that requires a decision. The conversation shifts from "she's pushing hard for her people" to "here is the objective picture."

Build the documentation before you need it. Track the numbers continuously, not just at budget time. The ask becomes almost incidental when the data has already made the case.

3. Build Advocates Before You Need Them

The worst time to start building support for a resource ask is in the meeting where you're asking for it. By then, it's too late.

Strategic advocacy is a long game. It means consistently making your team's contributions visible across the organization — not just up, but laterally. It means building relationships with peers whose work depends on yours, so they have a stake in your team being well-resourced. It means giving leadership visibility into what your team produces so that when budget season comes, your function doesn't feel like a line item — it feels like a dependency.

Think about it this way: who outside your immediate reporting line would speak up if your team's budget got cut? If the answer is "no one," that's a strategy gap, not a resource gap.

4. Name the Pattern, Not the Emotion

If you've been passed over for recognition repeatedly, there's a natural human impulse to say something like, "This is unfair," or "My team never gets credit." Completely understandable.

Also, strategically ineffective.

What works better: naming the pattern in organizational terms.

"I've noticed that the teams contributing to Project X haven't been mentioned in executive updates, even though they're driving a significant portion of the outcomes. I'd like to talk about how we make that contribution more visible — both for morale and for accurate organizational storytelling."

You're describing a real problem. You're not attacking anyone. And you're positioning visibility as something the organization benefits from, not just something you personally want.

That framing matters. A lot.

5. Recognize Your Own People Out Loud

You can't always control whether leadership recognizes your team. You can absolutely control whether you do — and whether you make that recognition visible to others.

Call out your team's wins in cross-functional meetings. Copy senior leaders on emails that highlight individual contributions. Nominate people for organizational awards. Write strong LinkedIn recommendations. Send specific, detailed thank-you notes that describe what someone did and why it mattered.

This does two things. It builds the kind of loyalty that makes retention a non-issue. And it establishes you as someone who builds people — which, at the director and VP level, is a core leadership competency that gets noticed.

Recognition you give has a way of coming back around.

The Bottom Line

You are not difficult for fighting for your team. You are doing exactly what a good leader should do. The system's discomfort with that is a systems problem, not a personal failing.

But your team needs you to be effective, not just righteous. So build the business case. Document everything. Create allies before you need them. Name patterns calmly and specifically. And recognize your people like it's your job — because it is.

You've got more power in this than you think. Use it strategically.

Well helloooo there! Like what you see here? We'd love to have you as a member of the Expansive Woman Project. We provide content, courses, and community for women who are done waiting for their next promotion. Membership is free, and always will be!

Click here to join now!